Blog

How Do Small Businesses Get Health Insurance in Arizona?

Steve Kelly, CBC, Kelly & Calloway Insurance Group, says benefits are usually the number two spend on a balance sheet after payroll. For a 10 or 20 person company that’s real money. And a lot of the time you’re buying it for the first time, because your own people asked for it.

Every business owner, the last thing they want to hear is employees complaining about this stuff, right? Because it’s a big spend, everybody needs it, and they want to keep employees.

How do small business owners get health insurance in Arizona?

In Arizona you’ve got four real options. You can buy a fully insured small group plan or go level funded. You can join a PEO. Or you can skip the group plan and use an HRA, which is basically giving people money to buy their own coverage.

We can price the first three next to each other. You don’t pay us for that, the carriers do.

Yes, we’re agnostic brokers. And what does that mean? That means that we contract with every single carrier and we’re going to show you everything and we’re going to make recommendations based on you, not on the carrier. They all pay the same amount of money. There’s no agenda for us per se. Every company is different. Some they have more money, they don’t. It just depends on what’s going on.

So do small businesses have to offer health insurance? If you’ve got fewer than 50 full-time and full-time equivalent employees, no. The mandate is only for an applicable large employer, and that’s the IRS’s term for 50 and up. HealthCare.gov says plainly there’s no penalty under that.

KFF runs a big employer survey every year. In the 2026 one the average plan was $9,804 for one person. Family was $28,303. That’s the whole premium, your part and the employee’s part together. I mean, a crew of 25 year olds is going to price a lot lower than that, and a team in their 50s probably higher.

Arizona has a tax credit for small businesses that start a plan. You don’t file for it, though. The insurance company claims it under A.R.S. 43-210 and A.R.S. 20-224.05. Then they take it off your premium. It’s only for groups of 2 to 25 employees.

You also can’t have offered coverage in the last six months, per the Arizona Department of Revenue. And the whole program has a yearly cap. I wouldn’t plan on it until you’ve called us or ADOR at (602) 255-3381.

The federal credit on Form 8941 is tougher. The IRS only gives it if you bought through the SHOP marketplace. And the CMS 2026 SHOP plan data doesn’t have a single SHOP plan in Arizona.

How many employees do you need to get a group health plan in Arizona?

In Arizona it’s two. State law says a small employer has at least two but not more than fifty eligible employees. You’ll see 1 to 50 on HealthCare.gov too. That’s the SHOP number, though, and Arizona small group plans go by the state one.

Carriers can have participation rules too. That’s how many of your eligible people have to sign up, and how much of the premium you have to cover. 45 CFR 147.104 allows that where state law does.

Now, on a small team it doesn’t take much to come up short. If that happens the carrier still has to take you, but only from November 15 through December 15. And every carrier’s rules are a little different, so call us and we’ll tell you what they’re asking for right now.

What are the alternatives to a traditional group plan?

Option Group size How it works Number to know
Fully insured small group 2 to 50 employees Set premium to the carrier Nov 15 to Dec 15 window
Level funded Small groups Monthly amount, rates off your own claims 38% of workers at 10 to 199 employee firms
PEO Up to about 50 to 60, per Steve Co-employment, PEO runs payroll Admin fee
QSEHRA Under 50, no group plan Reimburse individual coverage $6,450 single, $13,100 family (2026)
CHOICE (formerly ICHRA) Any size Reimburse individual coverage No annual max

Sources: A.R.S. 20-2301, 45 CFR 147.104, KFF, HealthCare.gov, Steve Kelly.

Steve says “25 to 35% of the premium that you pay to an insurance company is going toward prescription medications.”

Go to Walmart. They have Costco. Go to Costco. Don’t be afraid to shop out medication. These things are commodities. It’s the same meds.

I would say 80% of our small business clients are level funded, which is really just a mechanism that allows the group to get better insurance rates and allows the group to really take advantage of some of the things that I’m talking about. Now, maybe it only helps you a little bit now, but if you get everybody thinking about this and you’re in a level funded model which allows the insurance companies to underwrite just you as a company and not anybody else, they’re going to look at all your claims at the end of the year and if your claims aren’t that high, they’re going to give you a better renewal.

Steve calls a PEO “basically an outsourced HR team.” For a really small company that can be worth paying for, and we went deeper on it in PEO vs insurance broker: what changes once you have 50 employees.

So 10 employee group. I really can’t afford an HR person. I have employees in three different states. I really don’t understand insurance. I don’t really understand HR or compliance and then hiring people. And what if I fire somebody and I do it wrong and I get sued, et cetera. So this gives you a little bit of comfort knowing that you’re going to have this team. For that they’re going to charge you a fee, administration fee. I would say the model is great for small groups like that.

They’re masterful at playing a shell game on fees and moving the fees around, so it’s hard for you to understand. And they’ll flash a cheap medical rate, right. So I think the biggest takeaway from a PEO is ask them to be transparent about fee structure. Maybe they show you a great rate on workers comp and a great rate on your benefits, but understand what the other fees are and look at it as a collective whole.

I think a CHOICE arrangement is worth a look if your people are spread out over a few states, since you skip the group plan and everyone picks their own individual coverage.

Which insurance companies sell small group plans in Arizona?

Blue Cross Blue Shield of Arizona, UnitedHealthcare, Banner Health, Cigna, Aetna, the Banner and Aetna joint venture plan, and Antidote Health Plan of Arizona all filed 2026 small group rates here with CMS. That’s only fully insured plans. Level funded ones don’t get filed there. So the list won’t tell you who’s cheapest this year, and honestly that changes a lot.

Aetna has a joint venture partnership with Banner. And so Aetna specifically right now in Arizona has been wildly competitive against all the other carriers for the past 24 months. And one of the ways they’ve been doing this is through their partnership with Banner Aetna. Think about it. If they own part of the building and part of the doctors and part of the machines and everything else, right, they can reduce the cost of their health plan by trying to push people to their own facilities. So we have a lot of clients right now on Aetna. And we teach them this like, hey, you need an MRI, go to a Banner facility, price it out.

With Cigna it’s their clinics. Steve says there are “15 plus Cigna clinics around the state,” and if your people use them it works the same way.

So we’ll do like open enrollment meetings. We tell the employees. Think of this as a partnership, guys, between you, your employer and the insurance company. You guys are all in this together. And I know everyone blames the insurance companies, but when you understand how some of these nuances work, it will help you. And so if you think about how to use your health plan wisely like that, it will affect those rates come renewal, which affects you. It affects all of everybody.

If you want to see what your group would look like with a few of these carriers, you can start on our Employee Benefits page or contact us and we’ll go through it with you.

Tags :
Share This Post :